What’s the best way to sell a Beanie Baby?

So, if you want to sell your Beanie Babies and are ready for some negotiating, these online marketplaces are your best bet.
  1. eBay. eBay, one of the most popular online marketplaces in the world, is an excellent choice for selling Beanie Babies. …
  2. PlushCollector. …
  3. Etsy. …
  4. Sell2BBNovelties. …
  5. Sell4Value. …
  6. Mercari.

How do I find out what my Beanie Babies are worth?

Far and away, the most important thing about a Beanie Baby’s value is its tag. Oftentimes the same style of plushie was made for several years, and the only way to tell the age or rarity is with its tag.

Can you actually sell Beanie Babies for money?

Although you can sell Beanie Babies locally, you’ll get the most exposure and the most interest from buyers if you sell online. How you write a listing is important, however. These tips can help: Mention the name of your Beanie Baby in the listing name to make it easy to search.

Which Beanie Babies are worth the most money 2021?

Most Expensive Beanie Babies in 2021
Beanie BabiesPriceDate
Gobbles$24,000Sept. 29
Halo Bear$23,500Dec. 28
Princess Bear$20,000Nov. 25
Valentino Bear$20,000Nov. 7
Dec 30, 2021

Are McDonald’s Beanie Babies worth anything?

Are Mcdonalds Beanie Babies worth anything? Aside from the Princess Diana bear, most vintage Beanie Babies aren’t worth much. But one complete set of 2014 Teenie Beanie Baby Boos from McDonald’s is going for $850 on eBay, so you never know.

Are Beanie Babies worth anything 2022?

Many sites and fake ebay listings out there will claim the most valuable Beanie Babies in 2022 can be worth the price of a brand new home, and if you have any of the originals, you may be sitting on a small fortune.

What are the 9 original Beanie Babies?

The “Original Nine” Beanie Babies were: Legs the Frog, Squealer the Pig, Brownie the Bear (later renamed Cubbie the Bear), Flash the Dolphin, Splash the Whale, Patti the Platypus, Chocolate the Moose, Spot the Dog, and Pinchers the Lobster!

What errors makes Beanie Babies valuable?

Sometimes, the two dates conflict or are not the same and you will see that the hang tag has one date and the tush tag has another different date. And, if someone stained or dirtied the stuffed beanie baby toy or if someone wrote on the paper hang tag or tush tag, then that impacts value of the toy negatively too.

Are older Beanie Babies worth anything?

You’ll probably find these desirable stuffed animals in a beanie baby price guide. On the other hand, beanies from fourth and later generations aren’t among the beanie babies worth money. These little plush toys are known as common beanie babies and were mass-produced by the millions, lowering their collectible value.

Why are some Beanie Babies worth so much?

When I ask Boeker what makes a Beanie Baby worth anything, then or today, her answer is frank: “It’s what people are willing to pay for it.” Why some people are willing to pay anything for it is harder to square. For most, it’s unfathomable to imagine spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on a stuffed animal.

Do Beanie Babies really sell on eBay?

Some apparently rare Beanie Babies are listed on eBay for prices north of half a million dollars, with one seller asking $660,000 for a set of two Princess Diana special edition bears, and other sellers regularly posting Beanie Babies with prices in the tens of thousands of dollars.

Are Beanie Babies with PE pellets worth anything?

According to Verderame, some Beanie Babies with PE pellets are worth less than the ones with PVC pellets. If you have a Beanie Baby bear, Verderame advises the nose color — brown or black — of a bear, such as Valentino, could play a role.

How much is the millennium bear worth?

After researching eBay and other online marketplaces, we found a Beanie Babies “Millennium” bear that sold for $740 back on October 1, 2020. That’s not an asking price – it’s what someone paid for this bear.

Will Beanie Babies make a comeback?

Toy appraisers predict Beanies will never make a comeback, since the 1990s children—millennials—aren’t collecting like generations before them. “Sometimes these things that sound like a great idea just don’t pan out,” said Mr.

Is Princess Diana Beanie Baby worth anything?

Princess Diana Beanie Baby value

There’s not really an objective worth at play here. That’s not to say that they never sell for big money—Princess Diana Beanie Babies have occasionally been confirmed to fetch $1,000 or even $10,000. But most of the time, people aren’t spending an entire fortune on them.

How can you tell if Beanie Baby is first edition?

To ensure you’ve got a first edition, you need to look at the hang tag. 1st edition tags do not open like a book. The tag should also have the year 1993 or 1994 on the back. The originals got made in China or Korea.

What is a retired Beanie Baby?

When a Beanie Baby is retired, it is no longer produced by Ty, though if Ty has some remaining in its stock, these may be shipped to retailers.

Can Beanie Babies be donated?

Yes! Please be sure to fill out a Donor Form and include a form in each of your boxes/bags/envelopes! At this time, all donations must be shipped or delivered to our main facility in Chatsworth, Calif.

Where can I send my Beanie Babies?

What’s the best way to ship my beanie babies? The most cost effective way to ship your items is usually a flat rate box from the post office. You can pick up the boxes for free at your local post office or order them online from the post office website and they will be shipped to you at no cost.